Case Statement
Your client is the owner of a ski resort in Switzerland. The resort has noticed a decline in the profits in the last 6-8 months. You have been hired to analyse why
Initial Conversation
Candidate
Okay. I'd like to reiterate the problem statement- our client is the owner of a ski resort in Switzerland. The resort has noticed a decline in the profits in the last 6-8 months and I have to anaylse why, right?
Interviewer
Yes.
Candidate
Sure. To start with, is it a company specific problem or can it be noticed across the industry too?
Interviewer
Across the industry but we have borne the biggest brunt.
Candidate
Understood. Now I'd like to know more about our client to understand the situation better. What is a ski resort and does it operate as a single outlet or as a chain of resorts?
Interviewer
It's a single resort in Switzerland. The main highlight of all resorts in the area is their offering of ski activity in the high ends of Mont Font Glacier.
Candidate
Right. And who are the customers of our clients- domestic customers, tourists or both? Is there any additional service that they provide besides lodging and skiing activity? Lastly, do our competitors offer any additional service?
Interviewer
We are open for all but mainly our customers are tourists. No, mainly lodging and skiing with additional add-on activities like business halls, meals etc. The same is true for our competitors as well.
Candidate
Thanks a lot for that information. I'd like to dig deeper into the problem now. You mentioned that there has been a decline in profits. Profits is a function of Revenue and Costs. Has any of the two faced any changes in the last 6-8 months?
Interviewer
Yes, revenue has seen a decline
Candidate
Now, I'd like to break revenue into two components- number of customers * revenue per customer. Please let me know if you want me to focus on any of these?
Interviewer
Revenue per customer has remained more or less the same. However, the number of customers has seen a decline
Candidate
Okay. I'd like to further bifurcate the reasons by looking at them through internal and external factors. Given that the decline is across the industry, there might be external factors at play. However, since our client has seen a higher decline, I'd like to first look at the internal factors to the client.
Interviewer
Um, I think you can look at the external factors first. Maybe then we can see what factor is responsible for the higher intensity specific to our client.
Candidate
Sure, sounds good. Can I please know the split between domestic and tourist customers (in % revenue or number of people). Which of them has faced a major decline- for us and our competitors?
Interviewer
Let's say of the total people we serve, 70% are tourists and only 30% are domestic residents. The decline is majorly from tourists. This is true for other players as well.
Candidate
Right. I'll focus more on the tourist segment presently. Which countries form part of our customer base and is there any specific change in any of them?
Interviewer
Tourists flow in from multiple countries. However, those from Asian countries have seen the major decline.
Candidate
My hypothesis is that since all resorts in Switzerland have faced a decline and major change happened from the Asian countries, there is something specific to Asia that has caused a decline in revenue for our clients. Thus, I'd like to focus on that aspect now. I would like to consider the following levers- political, economical, social and miscellaneous.
Interviewer
Okay
Candidate
Firstly, under the political bucket, has there been any change in political relations between Switzerland and any Asian country? Is the government proactive in maintaining relations and is the foreign government eager to promote tourism? Lastly, I'd also like to know about the visa and documentation process.
Candidate
ondly, in economic lever- I'd like to take into account people's disposable income, rate of exchange, taxation policy, inflation etc.
Candidate
social factors, I'd like to know if there has been a shift in culture, religion, level of education, or mere preferences of people.
Candidate
ase let me know if you want me to focus on any of them in particular
Interviewer
None of them actually.
Candidate
Alright. I missed out on the miscellaneous factors wherein I'd like to see if any legal changes have happened with respect to changes in law, travel documentation, travel journey etc. I'd also consider if any environmental change is taking place that is pushing people away from flying to Switzerland.
Interviewer
Umm, not really.
Candidate
Sure, I have two questions- one, is there any change in any of the previously mentioned questions with respect to Switzerland, and second- are Asian people travelling in general but not to Switzerland?
Interviewer
No changes in Switzerland because that might also impact people flying from other countries, which is not happening. And yes, people are still travelling but not to Switzerland.
Candidate
Right. I would like to map the entire customer journey to see if any step in the process is causing this change. A person would first decide if they want to travel, then choose location, choose Switzerland, look for probable dates to travel, book tickets, reach airport, take flight (non-stop or layover), reach Swiss airport, travel to the resort, check-in, and so on.
Interviewer
Yes, you can look at the process before a person typically takes a flight.
Candidate
Sure, after choosing Switzerland, a person books tickets for the desired dates. Are resorts open all year round, do they have enough capacity? Are flights frequent? Is there any change in flying rate or the surcharges?
Interviewer
Yes, the rate of flights have increased i.e. it is digging a bigger hole in customer's pocket. You can move on to the recommendation.
Candidate
Sure. I will propose a few recommendations for our client that can be implemented in short term and in the long term. In short term, the client can increase promotion, reduce its profit margin and incite people to travel, offer discounts for off-season travel. They can also focus on increasing flyers from other countries so as to offset the decline from Asia. Next, they can also put efforts to increase domestic residents through active marketing and attractive offers.
Candidate
the long term, firstly they can lobby with the government regarding the flight rate. They can also talk to the bureau handling air travel norms. Both of these parties shall be incentivized to reduce the rate because it is adversely affecting the tourism revenue for the country as well as revenue for the flight operators in Switzerland. Also, they can collaborate with travel agencies who might buy bulk tickets and avail deeper discounts. These can then be sold to end consumers at lower rates.
Interviewer
Thank you. That'll be all.
Background Information
Location
Switzerland
Offer
Resort and skiing activity
Product
Resort
Industry
All players affected
Customers
Tourists and Domestic
Context Materials
Click on an image to view in full size